ADVANCEDBROWSE SUBJECTS
alive Academy
Alive Forum
Event Calendar
Health Retailer Search
Alive Awards
Alive Web Exclusives
Alive Australia


APEX Awards 2009

Find a store
Subscribe to our Free Newsletter!

Enlarge Font Printer Version Email It to a Friend
Death in a Bottle
by author David Crowe

The lives of millions of future Third World babies are at stake. Western medicine has persuaded the world that HIV-positive mothers should formula-feed whenever feasible–a decision taken with a teaspoon of data and a gallon of assumptions.

Few now disagree that, for most babies, “breast is best” to reduce the risk of death and illness due to diarrhea, intestinal disorders, meningitis, ear infections, respiratory infections, SIDS, and many other sicknesses. A World Health Organization (WHO) analysis showed that the risk of death in poor countries was three to four times higher in formula-fed infants in their first six months of life.

A Hasty Decision

After only two letters in medical journals, the Center for Disease Control (CDC) recommended against breastfeeding by HIV-positive women in 1985–with no analysis of the risks of formula feeding versus breastfeeding. This resulted in a virtual ban on breastfeeding by HIV-positive women in rich countries.

The only thing saving babies in the third world is that formula feeding is usually not affordable and always dangerous, often because of poor water quality. Only reluctantly are women allowed to continue breastfeeding. A spate of international initiatives is trying to change that.

Sloppy Science

Researchers involved in a Kenyan study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, Nov. 2001, admitted that, for the two-year length of their trial, they were unable to find increased mortality in the breastfed infants. However, they never properly defined breastfeeding. Data from mothers who formula-fed were used for the breastfeeding arm of the trial, and data from mothers who breastfed were used for the formula arm of the trial.

The trial was rigged in favour of formula by limiting participation to mothers who had access to treated water. A sign that there are more serious problems in the study was the higher death rate among mothers. This was blamed by the researchers on stress due to breastfeeding, but might also show that the trial was not properly randomized, with healthier women more likely to be told to formula-feed. Healthier women, of course, have healthier babies and are better able to care for them.

Breastfeeding vs. the Bottle

Research from South Africa reported in AIDS, Feb. 2001, showed that when breastfeeding is better defined as either “exclusive” (no other fluids or foods) or “mixed,” the rate of HIV transmission was similar between the “exclusive” group and those formula-feeding their babies (but higher in the “mixed” group). This research has been pooh-poohed by some because it was not a randomized trial of feeding method (but then it’s likely that the Kenya research was not randomized either).

In Oct. 2003, the Journal of Nutrition reported evidence that formula-feeding programs are dangerous. In a group of 148 babies of HIV-positive mothers in India, all hospitalizations during the first six months were in the formula-fed babies.

If you are concerned about this issue, before you support an AIDS charity, ask if they support breastfeeding and, if they do not, request the peer-reviewed health outcome studies that support their position.

David Crowe is a Calgary-based environmentalist and medical science critic. Contact him through alive.com.

Source: alive #274, August 2005

Back to top

See Related Content
Selenium
Imagine an antioxidant with the power to fight aging, halt heart disease, cut cancer rates, boost immunity, and speed healing. That's selenium, one of the most important disease-fighting nutrient.
Take the Pills, or We'll Take Your Kids!
Jane Doe of Montreal refuses to give toxic, lifelong medication to her two healthy sons. She loses custody of them as a consequence. Another woman in Montreal hears this and decides to have an abortion.
Better Breast Milk
You've just gone through a grueling nine-hour labou.
Breastmilk
Scientists have discovered a source of liquid gold. For decades they have tried to dismantle, analyze and recreate this amazing substance-to no avail. The only known source is a mother's breast--and it's not giving up its secrets easily.
Medicinal Ozone
Ozone therapy. I remember hearing about it 14 years ago from a medical doctor in Vancouver, Dr R. Hayward Rogers. He said it was an amazing treatment for difficult diseases.
Needed: New AIDS Strategy
The number of people with AIDS is horrifi.
AZT Life-Saving or Death-Dealing?
A South African court case might answer the question of whether AZT, the currently advertised AIDS drug, is life-saving or death-dealin.
Is Your Baby Ready for Solids?
At what age should baby have her first bite of solid food? And, when she's finally ready, what food should it be? Parents often wonder about starting solids, but luckily there is one expert you can always count on: your baby.
Living With HIV/AIDS Through Total Health Management
AIDS is the worst epidemic in history. More than 42 million people are now living with HIV-1, the virus that causes AIDS. In 2002 about 3.1 million people died of AIDS and five million people became infected.
Larrea: Nature's Medicine Chest
Larrea tridentata, or Larrea, recognized as being the oldest living plant on Earth, is native to the southwest deserts of the US and has a long history of use by Native Americans and European settlers. Records show that Larrea has been used as a "medicine chest for a wide range of infections and inflammatory conditions.
Top-Quality Breast Milk
Breast milk is always healthier for baby than infant formula, but not all breast milk is created equal: studies show that a mother's diet determines the amount and kinds of fat in her milk.
Breast Feeding Reduces Cancer Risk
I have always been a proponent of breastfeeding babies for a minimum of one year and preferably two years, if possible. Earlier research has shown that babies that are breastfed are less likely of becoming overweight or obese, have higher IQs, fewer behavioral problems, and a lowered risk of developing allergies.
Spin Doctoring
, claimed that the use of protease inhibitors.
Welcome Our Millenium Babies!
Our three favorite mothers made it through the past nine months in healthy, happy style. And they've been willing to talk about their experiences to share with you--so thanks all around! Without further ado, it's time to introduce the millennium babies.
Ozone Therapy for Aids
"The story of the most heinous of all crimes within the modern Canadian medical establishment [is that] a proven safe and effective treatment for alleviating AIDS symptoms is hidden from vie.
The Cause of AIDS: Theories
Mainstream doctors and popular media would have us believe that the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) causes AIDS; however, there is no consensus in the scientific community that this is tru.
Health Trade
Once again Seacure has shown itself to be a diverse product that is effective in many treatment.
The HIV Optimists
They keep appearing in ever-greater numbers on chat boards, websites, cafés, and off-the-grid support groups in people's homes-all the traditional gathering places for dissenters. They gather where they cannot be blocked, or harmed, or fired, or deleted, or told they don't exist, or that they are mad.
Baby Food 101
New parents often need guidance to feel confident about starting their baby on solids. This recommended feeding schedule should help. It shows that cereals are usually introduced at between four to six months of age, followed by fruits and veggies and then meat and dairy.

Back to top