ADVANCEDBROWSE SUBJECTS
alive Academy
Alive Forum
Event Calendar
Health Retailer Search
Alive Awards
Alive Web Exclusives
Alive Australia


APEX Awards 2009

Find a store
Subscribe to our Free Newsletter!

Enlarge Font Printer Version Email It to a Friend
BC Naturopathic Doctors Fight for their Rights-and Ours!
by author Rhody Lake

Not too long ago, huge rallies across the country protested Health Canada’s attempt to remove dozens of non-patented, commonly used traditional medicines from health food stores. The power of public protest was heard in Ottawa–David Dingwall, then minister of health, lost both his portfolio and his seat in Parliament!

Two health ministers later, our situation has not changed–it’s as precarious as ever.

Will vitamin dosages be “prescribed” only by medical doctors through the influence of drug lobbyists? Must we get government permission to use herbs in therapeutic dosages?

That little piece of federal history is already being repeated at a provincial level in British Columbia. Naturopathic doctors in BC are presently licensed to provide primary care without the use of drugs and surgery and have been for almost a century. Now many of the medicines they traditionally use have been removed and put on “prescription only” lists! And even though the
former BC government promised to establish a mandate to create access to these natural medicines by naturopathic doctors–the present government has not done so.

The Ministry of Health is threatening to further severely limit the scope of naturopathic doctors in BC–thus denying consumers access to valid and cost-effective health care choices, many of which patients have been depending on for survival. We are therefore doubly penalized. We pay, through compulsory Medicare, for a medical system that many do not use–and are prevented from spending our own after-tax dollars on health care of our choice.

That’s not logic–it’s not freedom–but it’s government!

What is the individual right of the consumer? Surely it’s his or her ability to have choice in health care and treatment, whether drugs and surgery or a non-drug alternative? But that’s not available in Canada. Powerful lobby groups and vested commercial interests control Canada’s Medicare system.

General practitioner Dr. Joel Lexchin says, “[Drug] companies generate a constant bombardment of advertising directed at doctors…physicians rely on this advertising for much of their knowledge [in prescribing].” Patients have been led to trust and believe in this fraudulent system and, in fact, the Canada Health Act only obliges the government to use citizens’ tax dollars for this “orthodox” treatment (drugs and surgery).

It’s time for a change!

The British Columbia Naturopathic Association (BCNA) has lobbied provincial governments on your behalf for decades. Now it’s asking us to step forward and make our voices heard. President of the association, Dr. Garrett Swetlikoff, warns, “Medical doctors have no formal training in complementary medicine, yet present regulations allow them to practise whatever and however they wish, while the experts in drug alternatives are shut down!”

The BCNA needs both our financial and letter writing support in order to hire appropriate lobbyists and demand that the elected government servants uphold our right and our wishes to the medicines of our choice. We are the people who pay their salaries!

Write to the BC ministers of health: Colin Hansen, Minister of Health Services, and Sindi Hawkins, Minister for Health Planning (contact information through Enquiry BC: 604-660-2421 or Enquiry BC@gems3.gov.bc.ca). Demand to know why they are limiting your ability to access safe, effective health care. Write your protest to your local newspaper as well as your MLA. And please contribute to the BCNA lobby effort by sending a donation to the BCNA, 2238 Pine Street, Vancouver, BC, V6J 5G4.

It’s for your health.

Rhody Lake is a freelance researcher and journalist, and former editor of alive.

Source: alive #246, April 2003

Back to top

See Related Content
A New Breed of Doctors
"While going to university, [medical doctors] are somehow taught to close their minds." So said Vancouver talkshow host Croft Woodruff in a recent interview.
BC's Oldest Naturopath
Eighty-six-year-old naturopath Fred Loffler has been known to kill time before a talk by standing on his head. It's not hard to imagine as the ex-wrestling champion and Olympic Marathon contender strides to the stage. He's wiry, bald and throws his arms out to punctuates his words.
Victory For Medical Choices
Charges against Dr Hulda Regehr Clark were recently dismissed, as happy supporters prepared to continue the battle. Attorney Steve Dillon's office gave notice that the judge granted the defence Motion to Dismiss. Clark was charged with practicing medicine without a license in Indiana.
Doctors Under Fire
Canadian doctors are being harasse.
Transfusions
Blood has become one of the most scrutinized fluids of our time. Canada's tainted blood scandal left thousands of people infected with hepatitis C and shook public confidence in the Canadian Red Cross. Yet there is more information threatening to rock the medical establishment and causing people to demand safer alternatives..
Beware Nursing Home Nutrition
Hospitals and nursing home dieticians don't seem to have the recipe for good nutrition. Caregivers don't know how much of anything patients are really consuming.
9-1-1 Naturopath
I remember visiting my grandmother in the hospital after she collapsed due to heart failure. Without the skilled knowledge of the paramedics who arrived at her home, she would have died.
The Downside of Doping Up
Citius, altius, fortius. Swifter, higher, stronger. This Olympic motto is based on the Greek ideals of discipline, dedication, sweat and fair play. Today it has a shadowy side.
Treating Toxic Bodies With Environmental Medicine
The scientific and medical world of the 19th and 20th centuries was dominated by the germ theory. The present century is dominated by chemicals and toxins.
The Nature of Natural Healing
Never before has there been such a great interest in natural self-healing--and such a resistance to it. Natural healing requires re-visioning. It cannot be viewed through the magnifying glass of modern medicine that sees everything in small, unconnected parts.
Vitamin Potencies On The Block-An International Fight

If you take mega doses of vitamin C to help fight heart disease, for instance, you may soon find that a 60-milligram tablet is the maxi.
Spring Clean Your Liver
It may not feel like it yet, but soon the frost will melt and springtime will arrive--a natural time for growth, renewal and regeneratio.
The Boucher Institute of Naturopathic Medicine
There's excitement in the air as you step through the solid wooden doors of Canada's newest naturopathic college in New Westminster, BC. Or perhaps a better phrase to describe the feeling is "pioneer spirit.
Let Food Be Your Medicine and Medicine Be Your Food
Isn't it absurd that we call the modalities of natural healing "alternative medicine"? Obviously, "alternative" refers to something other than the accepted or the standard. The opposite to "alternative medicine" is what we now call orthodox or allopathic medicine, which then makes it the standard.
Common Prescriptions Linked To Cancer
Canadians spend an estimated $15.5 billion annually on drugs, according to the Canadian Institute for Health Information. This represents 15.2 per cent of total health-care spending.
Best of Both Worlds
bridging the medical divide

For decades, a medical war has rage.
Dr. Krop Loses, Environmental Medicine Wins
Dr. Krop's case has brought about a revolution in the highercourt of public opinion, which demands safe medicine and a return tounpolluted planetary life-support systems.The 13-year trial of Dr. Jozef Krop may be over, but its impact on thefuture of environmental medicine in Canada will be lasting.
Drug Approval in Canada
The tragic death of fifteen-year-old Vanessa Young did more than send one family into despair. It highlighted serious-and life-threatening-issues within Canada's drug approval system.In March 2000, Vanessa died of cardiac arrest in her father's arms.
Canadian Drug Surveillance: A Sick System?
Pop a pill. Cure your headache.... Damage your liver? In recent years, critics have pointed fingers at Canada's drug monitoring system, claiming that inefficiencies in how drugs are tracked after approval contribute to needless injuries and deaths.
Where Do Doctors Get Their Information on Drugs?
Accurate information about doctors' sources of information can be obtained by.
Fighting for Natural Health
The passion in Stefan Doll's voice, during our hour-long telephone interview, is especially evident when he talks about his St John's wort oil, winner of two Alive awards for excellence.
Good News for Canada's Newest College
At the campus in New Westminster, BC, they paid their tuition, bought textbooks and attended classes - all without a guarantee that they'd be able to practise once graduating from the program.
A Sign of the Times
The strides gained in the naturopathic profession have been phenomenal given its near extinction only a few decades ago. Naturopathic medicine has hit the mainstream with a bang.
Fair Trade?
Globalization and free trade policies have been promoted by many large western governments, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and the World Trade Organization and opposed by people worldwide.
False Claims by Drug Companies
Late last year we heard the terrifying news that several antidepressant drugs prescribed for adolescents were unsafe, and have led to suicide in some children.
Take Control of Your Health
It's spread like cancer, controlling seed companies, national agriculture, mainstream food producers, international media, and government.
Taxes That Make Sense
Every time there's a national election, candidates make promises about tax cuts. We hear endless dialogue in the media about the inadequacies of our universal health-care program and the out-of-control costs of funding that system.
Drug Flaws
It's a sunny Sunday morning as you reach for the grapefruit juic.
Backward Medicine
"The doctor of the future will give no medication, but will interest his patients in the care of the human frame, diet and in the cause and prevention of disease. Thomas A.
Lifesaver or Billion-Dollar Industry?
Coronary artery bypass surgery took centre stage in 2004 when former US President Bill Clinton underwent emergency bypass surgery.
First Steps Toward a Healthier Future
If you've ever suffered a health problem or been close to someone who has, you know how improving nutrition can improve health. Knowing what foods to eat is just as important as knowing why we need to eat them.
Take a Pill
Governments are increasingly made uneasy by conflicting impulses surrounding the drug industry. It used to be that they couldn't live without the industry. Now they are realizing that they cannot live with it either.
Naturopathic Medicine and Bone Cancer Prevention
The general public perception is that there is very little an individual can do to reduce his chances of getting bone cancer. This view can be challenged, because enhancing the body's ability to resist bone cancer is within our reach.
Gentle Giants
They're housed one by one in small cages. Injected with strains of HIV and hepatitis, they scream and thrash in protest, only to be silenced by dart guns. Chimpanzees, our closest primate relatives, have been used in biomedical research for the past 15 to 20 years.
Selling Sickness: How the World's Biggest Pharmaceutical Companies Are Turning Us All into Patients
"With less than 5 percent of the world's population, the United States and Canada make up almost 50 percent of the global market in prescription drugs, write Australian health reporter Ray Moynihan and Canadian drug policy researcher Alan Cassels in their book, Selling Sickness.
Growing Doses of Acceptance for Complementary Medicine
Jill Franklin's story is a tribute to the power of human spirit. It also exemplifies the state of complementary and alternative medicine in Canada.
A Question of Ethics or Ethical Questions?
You may have heard some fairly wild claims made by proponents of natural products. Even wilder claims, however, seem to be coming from the pharmaceutical industry. To find out more, you might want to start by asking your physician, but medical doctors usually have little or no training in natural remedies.
Meaningful Makeovers Part II
Last month you met Rob, a writer, and Toni, a costumer, who each want to become fitter and healthier. They've begun their alive makeovers by undergoing a naturopathic assessment to discover what they'll need to work on to achieve optimal health.
Consumer Confidence- at a Cost
Consumers can expect to pay more for natural health products in the coming years. But at least they'll know what they're getting. New Health Canada regulations will affect everything from manufacturing and distributing to licensing and labelling.
Integrative Medicine
The progressive educational experience of one Vancouver naturopathic doctor will forever influence his practice and his patients, and reveals the future of medicine.
Nutrients In the News
There have been 32 adverse reactions to vitamin C as of May 2008, according to the Canada Vigilance Online Database hosted by Health Canada. But hold on! Before you get nervous and chuck out the bottle that you just bought, let's dig deeper.
Healthy Differences of Opinion
The election may be over, but accountability has just begun. alive asked the five major parties about their positions on natural health and the future of the now-dead Bill C-51. With a new political landscape in Ottawa, Canadians will want to understand the implications for natural health. Will the promises made during the election campaign be acted upon by our new government?
Natural Health Regulations
The Natural Health Products Directorate (NHPD) is the branch of Health Canada responsible for licensing natural health products (NHPs). As the Canadian natural health industry grapples with a product-licensing deadline of January 1, 2010, the process seems mired in misinformation and industry confusion.
Holistic Health Care
If you’re a holdout because you don’t know the difference between naturopaths and homeopaths, let this introductory guide, well, guide you.

Back to top