> Emotional and Mental Health

Whistle-blowers simply tell the truth, which, strangely, can be a high stakes endeavour.

In prison, people get dubbed ratters and snitches for the deed–and pay dearly. But should there be a similar price to pay for those brave and principled individuals in our midst who dare to step forward to tell it like it is?

Debate around the issue has taken on greater urgency as neoconservative trends in society tip the balance toward private sector interests and profit making. In their push to balance budgets, North American governments have gradually reduced spending and regulatory oversight.

The corporate sector has stepped in to fund hospitals and universities and their research activities. Which means the public interest often takes second place to the interests of those paying the piper.

Societal Moles

The Vancouver-based Labour Environmental Alliance Society argues that the goings-on beyond the governmental garden gate are ever harder to come by, what with increased media concentration, freedom of information run-arounds, and restrictions on civil servants speaking out.

As a result, whistle-blowers have become a critical cog in the system, playing a pivotal role in safeguarding tax dollars, protecting public health and safety, and watching out for the environment.

The Watergate imbroglio that led to Richard Nixon’s impeachment in 1974 was all about a whistle getting blown. So was the tainted blood scandal in Canada. Ditto the Quebec sponsorship fiasco. In all these cases, if someone didn’t blab, the public might never have found out.

Altruism Becomes Masochism

But blowing a whistle can have consequences dramatic and dangerous enough to provide the plotline for a Hollywood thriller.

Indeed, All the President’s Men put the Watergate story on the silver screen. Erin Brockovich, released in 2000, related the real-life saga of a single mother taking on a California power company. In 2005 The Constant Gardener depicted a fictional yarn involving the wife of a British diplomat murdered in Kenya after exposing wrongdoing by a pharmaceutical company.

Examples abound of people who step forward to speak out and then become caught up in a melodrama of miseryand mayhem.

“Why blow the whistle if the reward for heroism is martyrdom?” asks Joanna Gualtieri, director of the Federal Accountability Initiative for Reform (FAIR), based in Ottawa. Gualtieri put that question to MPs at a May 2006 Commons hearing into the Harper government’s accountability legislation. The law features whistle-blower protection that is considered inadequate by her organization.

Gualtieri knows all about the martyrdom involved in wieldinga whistle.

She is suing her former bosses in the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade. The lawyer and former public servant, now 46, wound up first on stress leave and ultimately out of a job after she complained in 1992 about Canadian diplomats wasting millions of dollars on rented residences abroad when government-owned homes were available to them. She opted to take on the Department of Justice in a legal battle that has derailed her career and consumed her life.

Interestingly, Watergate deep throat W. Mark Felt–former FBI deputy director–working through two sworn-to-secrecy journalists at the Washington Post, was able to keep his identity secret for 30 years, and hence escape retribution. His experience is rare.

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

FAIR, on its website, warns would-be whistle-blowers: “This is a very dangerous thing to do, and few people have the courage required.”

Typically, whistle-blowers who express concerns to their superiors are jollied along for a while but soon receive poor performance reviews. They may be re-assigned to less meaningful work, become the object of smear campaigns, and be shunned by colleagues. Wrongdoers meanwhile retain the credibility and authority of their positions, with the resources of the organization fully behind them.

Those who mean to do good tend to wind up discredited, unemployed, broke, clinically depressed, and in some cases, suicidal. Often, they leave their home communities. The FAIR website further warns, “It is not unusual for whistle-blowers to receive death threats.”

Barbara Yaffe is a national political columnist at the Vancouver Sun. Her column is read across Canada in CanWest newspapers. Born in Montreal, Yaffe has lived in Vancouver for 19 years.

Source: alive #311, September 2008